He directed three features that really impressed me as they were all in categories of film that I usually avoid as they drive me nuts, and he did great things with them: Truly, Madly, Deeply, The English Patient, and The Talented Mister Ripley. Three really really good films, those.
He also made a short film that I find most remarkable, as it shouldn't work at all. He directed Samuel Beckett's Play for the Beckett on Film project of several years ago.
Now I love Beckett, especially post-1963 Beckett. Play may be my favorite theatre text of all time (the other contenders for this are also Beckett: Not I and Rockaby). I am a bit fanatical in my feelings about how Beckett's work should be performed. I may be a theatre director who feels that directors should have a pretty wide latitude it terms of textual interpretation, sure, but that you only go as far as you can while remaining true to the text, or illuminating it in some way. With Beckett, sure, you can add things, if you like, and ignore stage directions. However, you should be aware that when it comes to Sam you almost certainly will be WRONG and MAKING BAD THEATRE. I don't think there's another playwright I'd say that about with complete certainty.
And to my mind, making a film of a Beckett theatre text is a BAD THING. Beckett write plays specifically for theatre and radio and television, and one film. And he understood all of those media. He also wrote prose and poetry and I'm nauseated by the apparently common idea that those works of his also belong on a stage. He did in each separate medium what worked best in that medium, and they should stay that way. No matter how well done, it is still Doing Well What Ought Not To Be Done At All.
That said . . . he did supervise a BBC TV version of Not I, which . . . ain't the play but it's nice to hear Billie Whitelaw's voice (and see her mouth) do it. And I do indeed have all sixteen of the Beckett on Film movies on tape and watch my favorites with some regularity -- there are only a couple of outright clunkers in the bunch (Footfalls and, unfortunately, Rockaby at the top of that list), a couple of boring versions of lesser works, a number of so-so films of excellent performances (Not I, That Time, and A Piece of Monologue especially), some good films that aren't altogether true to the plays but adapt them well enough (Mamet's version of Catastrophe, Charles Sturridge's version of Ohio Impromptu with Jeremy Irons) and two outright great films that find cinematic ways to adapt Beckett that really work (Damien O'Donnell's What Where and the Minghella).
So here, behind the cut, is Anthony Minghella's film of Samuel Beckett's Play, featuring Kristin Scott-Thomas, Alan Rickman, and Juliet Stevenson -- and I'll be putting most of my video and photo entries behind LJ cuts from now on, as I've been getting complaints about loading errors and crashes from people trying to look at my page (mainly with Firefox users, it seems) since I've been including more of these things here. Hopefully this will reduce the problems.
( PLAY )
Enjoy. RIP AM.